My 21 year old son has dropped out of college #3 after having transferred out of his first 2 schools. He has gotten a job at a liquor store working 32 hours per week with the possibility of extra hours being paid under the table. He thinks his hourly wage will be $9 or $10 – he didn’t ask! I have paid all of his expenses thru school (tuition, room & board, car, gas, etc). His stepfather and I are professionals, making a good living, but we have 3 other children between us and are paying their entire college expenses. I think my son should start paying rent, but I’m not sure what to charge him. He hasn’t gotten his first check yet and I think he’s going to be in for a big reality check when he sees what he nets out of that 9 or 10 dollar hourly wage! Your guidance would really be appreciated.
There is so much I don’t know about your family, I could write a book about it.
So, you are going to have to take everything I say and apply it to specific family and its needs.
1) You have fulfilled your parental duty (if there even is one) of trying to send this MAN to college. THREE TIMES.
2) You have done something right in that he wants to work and has secured himself a job. Seriously. You can find many a parent where the child won’t even do that. So, good on him.
3) YES, he should be paying rent and utilities. At minimum. Call a meeting and work this out with him. You can go as hard core or easy on this as you choose, but you MUST do this if you don’t want to completely handicap him. Create consequences TOGETHER.
4) Do not let your boundaries go (unless life and limb are at risk). Hold up the consequences. This may become painful, but this is the parenting work.
5) Clearly (or not) this man needs to sort himself out and college may or may not be in his future. Your goals are to help him become self-sufficient, ASAP, with the acknowledgement that you have been bailing him out for almost four years. He is not going to change overnight. So, slow, steady, BOUNDARIED, and loving.
Good luck!
Hi, I love your chats and read them all! I was holding our just-turned-two year old the other day and out of nowhere she said the phrase, “no cry here – cry at home” several times. When I repeated the story to the daycare provider the next morning, she said, “yes, we tell them, ‘don’t cry now, cry at home’. While this certainly explains the melt down’s she has nearly every evening (combined with being 2!), I am really saddened by this. We really love her daycare, but I cannot imagine telling little one’s they are not allowed to cry! I have sensed that my child is stressed out by daycare and I think part of that stress comes from keeping her emotions pent up during the day. Is this worth switching daycare’s over? Is this common? What do you think?
I think that this is awful.
TRULY. AWFUL. Good grief, WHY would people in charge of TODDLERS not welcome crying. *head hits on desk over and over*
Only you know what your family can do, but yes, take that sweet baby out of there unless they are willing to drop that atrocious rule, STAT.
Hi Meghan and Amy! We’re at a loss about what to do with our 8 year old daughter. For the past few months she has been sullen, moody, and generally just unpleasant over 50% of the time. We’ve ruled out any medical issues, she gets approx. 10-11 hours of sleep each night, TV time is limited to an hour (if that) during the week. She doesn’t eat the way she should, but we can’t control what she eats at school (even with a packed lunch) and have had her pediatrician discuss healthy eating with her. She alludes to friend issues, but what she describes seems like normal 8 year old stuff. We’re really, really, really trying to love her through it but it’s getting harder and harder to react lovingly and not punish/yell/snap when she’s yelling at us or her brother. Please help!
Hmmmm….
I don’t know, but I would look more into the friend thing. Ask at school if the teachers have noticed anything…
And many 8 year old’s have a surge of hormones that can make them very moody, so it can be normal, too.
Also, if you are tip-toeing around her moods and sassiness, that can also make children feel immature, hence more sullen, etc.
I am not suggesting that you punish her, but I am suggesting that you get snuggly with her (as much as possible) relaxed and loving and say something like, “I have noticed that things have been pretty prickly around here. And I want you to know that even when you are prickly, Dadday and I love you, no matter what. We may have to stop some of the behaviors sometimes, but we love you and want to hear everything in your heart. Always.” And then leave it there. Do this often and see if she starts to open up…
Hi Meghan, I have 2 adorable girls: ages 2 & 4. These 2 are either the best of friends or each other’s worst enemy; there is no in between. I need to get them stop fighting like cats and dogs because it’s driving me bonkers! I don’t want to do spankings because I never had that growing up. Are timeouts suitable? If so, is there a good rule of thumb for time outs?
Amy here: Make sure to read Meghan’s recent column right here about sibling fighting.
Time-out’s are very temporarily helpful and will end up causing SO MUCH MORE stress for you and they.
Here’s the thing: You have to manage their play more.
They are NOT going to able to work things out when the play goes south, they are too little, so keep role-modeling loving play and break them up when they start getting prickly.
This is exhausting and annoying, but it will NOT last forever.
My three-year-old boy transitioned from crib to toddler bed with no problems. Several weeks ago, however, he began sleeping on his rug, rather than in the bed. He says he doesn’t want to pee in his bed overnight (We got him Paw Patrol sheets, and he may be worried about soiling them). That was never really a problem for him, though, and I explained that I can change the bedsheets much more easily than I could clean the rug, but he is unmoved by this logic. The first few nights he did this, we moved him into the bed after he fell asleep, but now we just leave him on the floor. Are we doing the wrong thing?
Hmmm, no. Sounds okay to me. It is clear he loves his little sheets, and he sounds like a worrier….
I would maybe go in and “spill” something on them in front of him, say sorry, have him help you strip it and wash them, remake it. (on a Saturday).
This promotes flexibility and making friends with mistakes! Mommy spills, pees happen, and it’s all good. Our family is okay with all of it.
See if that cannot help him….
🙂
So I have two completely opposite points. (1) yes charge some kind of rent try to help him understand money and budgeting on a limited income. (2) any chance of ADHD?
Ahhhh, you are wise.
Yes…is there something going on there we don’t know about? LD’s? Other issues? Diagnosed or not?
Good point!
Some meds and proper therapies could change everything!
Should a 7 year old child be told that his father is in jail? Father and mother have been separated for almost two years after an incident of domestic violence, which the child witnessed. Father has developed a drug issue and has not had much visitation with the child lately, although he has had some spotty visitation. Now he has violated his parole and will likely be going to prison for a year or two. Child lives with his mom and mom’s boyfriend, where life is stable and there is no fighting or abuse. The mother wants to tell the child that his father will be going to prison, since he won’t be seeing his father for a while, and she feels it is better that he knows the truth than feel like his father abandoned him. Other people are telling the mother it would be better to tell the child his father moved away because child goes to a nice school where none of the other kids fathers are in prison and they are worried he will talk about it with his classmates. What would you recommend? Despite the father’s flaws the child misses and loves him.
NO LYING ALLOWED.
You know the saying, “we are only as sick as our secrets?”
Well, adults DO that to kids when we lie. We make US sick and we hurt the children.
You stick to the facts of the matter. “Daddy was told by people so not break certain rules, and he broke them. So, now Daddy has to go to a place called ___________. It is where men go when they have broken the rules of our city/state/country. We don’t know how long he will be there, yet, but we will write him and visit him. He is sad he is going, and we are sad he is going to. We can send him pictures and we can call him.”
That’s the easy part. The hard part is that this little girl may have a lot of contradictory feelings about this and her father. She loves her father, but he hurt her mother. She want to be with him, but her situation is better now.
Just don’t ask her to not be sad or that she cannot see him, etc.
Keep all lines of communication open. Keep all feelings open. Get extra support for the child, too. (Play therapy is THE BEST).
Good luck…
Because I can’t believe that 2-year-olds are actually holding in their emotions for a whole day. What on earth is going on at that day care?!
I know.
Here’s the deal (I want to clarify WHY two year old’s cannot and should not hold in feelings).
1) preschoolers are 100% driven by emotion. It is appropriate and normal. This is how the brain develops and grows.
2) The expression of these emotions are how they communicate.
3) Loving adults receive these emotions and help the child either adapt or cry or the adults hold boundaries…but the emotions come out, all the same.
4) When the emotions are told to STOP or they are punished, the child literally gets stuck. The child does not feel safe. The child becomes stressed, anxious, and worst of all, shut down. They stop maturing.
5) Hence, every single adult who work with children must allow feelings to move in a loving, gentle, and warm manner.
I have two adult daughters (43 and 46) who will not talk or correspond to one another. Any ideas on how to bring them together?
No.
Seriously, no.
They are full-blown adults and do not communicate.
I don’t know if they are friendly and just don’t talk, or if they are angry and hate each other or if it is one-sided or what.
But, why now?
Ask yourself that.
My 3.5 year old is resisting the potty. With his older brother, we used the encouragement to be a “big boy” and praised him. But the little one says “I’m not a big boy, I’m still tiny!” and seems to want to stay in diapers. He’s honestly getting too big for the largest diapers! He will occasionally sit and has successfully gone a few times, but most of the time just refuses to try. I don’t want to force him and cause issues and stress. Should I wait? His preschool keeps making hints that we should have him trained by now. He also has an expressive speech delay that he is making great progress in speech therapy with, so I’m wary of putting more stress on him now.
Uggg, I am getting super-pissed at daycares and preschools today.
GOOD GRIEF.
Speech delays + wanting to be little = WAITING
NO PUSHING.
Buy the pull-ups, speak not more word about the potty, and tell these teachers (nicely) to LET IT GO.
GRRRRRRR.
My spouse undermines me with the children very absent-mindedly. I have made it clear several times that I do not want my children to eat in their bedroom because of the crumbs on their carpet. Sometimes I come home from work and see crumbs and juice boxes in the kids’ room and it gives me “the cat is away so the mice will play” feeling. My concern is that Daddy always gets all the “cool” points for being more lenient and me, the mean ol’ mom, gets to be less of crowd favorite and more of a rule enforcer. How can I express that I need more support from my husband? I don’t want to sound whiny, but I’m tired of being the mean parent because my husband thinks it’s ok to have less rules when I’m away.
Hmmmm.
I need to know how old the kids are here…
But in any case, you need a date night.
You need wine and yummy food and flirting and sweetness.
You need to speak from the heart (this about feeling like the crappy parent here) and you guys need to find something in the middle.
Maybe he is going to vacuum the crumbs and wipe up the juice and you are going to turn your head?
Maybe the kids can step up?
There are a million solutions, but they all begin with loving communication between you and hubs.
My preschool aged daughter refuses certain foods. She won’t even give certain veggies a try, but instead shuns them and begs for snacks. She is so stubborn that I get afraid (despite pediatrician saying she is healthy) she isn’t eating enough! How can I get veggies to become more appealing to a picky 4 year old?
Check the fear at the door, make delicious dinner comprised of food she will mostly eat, enjoy your food, and don’t say anything about the veggies.
Make the dinner about enjoyment and chatting.
“I saw a cloud today that looked like a giant roaring lion!”
Make preschool chitchat. Smile. Eat. Repeat.
Watch what happens when you let the worry go. I mean, REALLY LET IT GO.
As the mother of a toddler girl, I spend a time lot reading about the impact of media and social messages on young girls. The majority of what I seem to read focuses on avoiding topics like categorizing people by weight/appearance, and focusing compliments away from weight/appearance and on strength/smarts/effort instead. I am in my early 30s and grew up in a house that did just this for the most part. I was complimented when I worked hard on projects, played a sport well, earned high grades, etc. But I was never helped along in the appearance department by my parents. We ate relatively healthy foods at family dinner, but I was never advised to consider my activity level and calorie intake together, which meant that in my 20s I struggled to maintain a healthy diet and weight. I was NEVER complimented on my appearance, and I spent at least a decade trying to figure out how to feel beautiful and choose clothes and hair styles that complimented my natural features. I feel like my folks went overboard in avoiding these topics, but what I read now as a mom still reinforces that you can’t compliment a child’s appearance, you have to say they are “strong on those monkey bars” etc. Is it possible that we are going too far in the other direction? I want to have a positive relationship with my daughter as she grows up, not set her up to be weight-obsessed, or to seek affirmation of her beauty because her mom never gave her that. Can you weigh in on this?
I think you wrote everything that needs to be said.
Extremes, in EITHER DIRECTION, are harmful.
And whenever we adopt too strict a way, “ALL TALK OF LOOKS IS BAD” then we become a slave to a rule and ignore the needs and desires of our children.
When my daughter looks beautiful (be it in sports clothes or a fancy dress), I say it.
When she has worked hard and I’m proud of her effort, I say it.
Just try to keep it somewhere in the middle of NORMAL. And about her. And not you.
Follow your instincts. You are on track.
I am still amazed at the woman a few weeks ago who is getting her Little One to floss, as well as the mom who started brushing teeth with her 14 month old!! We started brushing teeth when our child turned 2 (what is the right age??) and she is all over the place. She is struggling to hold the tooth brush the correct way, and ends up sucking the (kid’s) toothpaste off the brush instead of brushing. We help her and talk about it a lot, and she has made some advances, but it is a challenge, no doubt. We are trying to keep it light and fun to keep her interested in doing it. Are there repercussions from this approach? When are you supposed to take them to the dentist for the first time? Thank you! I love your chats!
Keep it light and easy-breezy. Brush your teeth together and sing a song. Make it a game and sing a song.
Your pediatrician is the best person to ask about teeth and dentists, but you sounds like you are on the right track.
Don’t get stuck in these small battles. 🙂
6 yo son has been talking incessantly about a girl and two boys in class who enjoy discussing body parts. Questions about breasts abound; we answer. The girl in question asked to see his penis. When asked how he responded, he ducked his head (preeeeeeeeeeetty sure he complied). Reiterated which body parts are ours alone or ok for family to see during changing/bathing, etc, which aren’t, touching, etc. Other than asking more questions about his day and checking that he’s not flashing his parts around, is that the end? Do we contact the teacher to keep an eye out? Do we give names of the other kids (because while I know body interest is perfectly normal in first graders, something about her asking and the words she used just seems off).
Hmmmm.
I am thinking as a mom and a coach.
As a mom, I would drop a little line to the teacher giving her a heads-up, but I wouldn’t want her to make a big deal of it. (that adds shame which makes for weird feelings about normal stuff). So, if this teacher is wise to how kids are, she will just be on the look-out and help them stop flashing in their bits about.
Keep listening to your son. If his interest is peaking, this is ABSOLUTELY the time to go get a book from the library and share it together. I love that he is talking to you, so keep this open! NO SHAME. The body is beautiful, amazing, and so cool to learn about. Keep that ethos.
🙂