Hi Amy and Meghan! I have an almost two-year-old and a newborn, and I’m struggling with my toddler’s impishness. She will do things she knows not to do – the big one is throwing food and her sippy cups on the floor during mealtime – even when I catch her just before and tell her to stop. And then she’ll look back at me and grin, so it’s obvious she’s just testing boundaries as opposed to actually not knowing that she shouldn’t throw things. I have a hard enough time not laughing; she’s adorable even when she’s misbehaving. But what can I do to discourage that behavior? I don’t really think she’s old enough to get what punishment is (for example, taking away the food or cup), but maybe I should do that? I don’t want to make her afraid to test boundaries; I just want her to stop throwing her food!
Firstly, congrats on recognizing that these behaviors as developmentally normal. This will take you far in your parenting life.
So, are you actively encouraging this boundary-pushing? No, not really. Are you discouraging it? Not really. Your two year old can see that you are smiling and not bothered, and I am not going to guide you toward becoming angry and punitive.
So, just react appropriately to her behavior. Tough advice, huh?
If you need to say no, say it and move her along. It doesn’t need to be a big production, just have a serious, calm face. You could, in all probability, say no almost constantly…so create boundaries and routines that say the no’s for you. Keep moving the child forward without much ado.
Resist resist resist resist resist punishment. If anything, keep your smiling and easy-going way about you. You will need it. When things get tough, get back to boundaries and routines.
My boys (ages 4 and 8) are using lots of mean words when talking. Certainly they call each other names, but then they also use the words directed towards me, their father, and others outside the family. What’s the appropriate response from me? Ignore? Correct? Time out? Duct tape their mouths? 🙂 Thanks!
Errr, no duct tape (I know you were kidding on that one).
So. do not time out…but there needs to be some boundary and stat. Under no circumstances (unless your children have a brain disorder or other special needs I don’t know about) is there a case where the children can call people outside of the family names. I would immediately remove the children from the scenario, firmly speak to them, apologize if needed, and move on from there.
Within your home and your family, I would be interested in seeing how discouraged the children are. There is NORMAL boundary-pushing with all children when it comes to taboo issues like this, but I would be more interested in understanding why there is so much of it.
Are they only getting attention when they use bad language? Is there something happening in the family that is traumatic? Hard to manage? Are the parents speaking respectfully to the children and each other? Are you responding too softly to the language..meaning, do the children feel in charge of the dynamic?
Do NOT begin to time out them or formally punish them, but definitely STOP the language and get curious about what is happening.
My son has been hitting us for years now. It has gotten a TON better, and it really only happens occasionally now, and mostly with his Dad. But this has gone on long enough, that I would really like to just nip this. I feel like we’ve tried everything: time outs, time-ins, getting low and calmly telling him that “we don’t hit”, talking about what else we can do besides hit, etc. Please help us stop this behavior for good!
Hitting is a sign of frustration.
Go to the roots…what is frustrating him?
And can you change that and/or help him adapt to what frustrates him?
The hitting is a symptom (and it is a GOOD sign it has slowed down, maturity is around the corner), so keep loving him through this. Occasional hitting for 6 year old’s is NORMAL. Resist nipping it in the bud, you will create more problems.